3 Guys and a Flick...Movies, Rants, Reviews...Your Welcome. Movie review Podcast
🎙 Podcast Episode 249

Heart Eyes

Join the Guys as they celebrate Valentine’s Day the only way this podcast knows how — with awkward coworker chemistry, romantic comedy chaos, and a masked killer who thinks couples therapy should involve a sharp object.

Release Date February 7, 2025
Runtime 97 minutes
Director Josh Ruben

3 Guys and a Flick — Episode 249

Heart Eyes (2025)

Details

Movie TitleHeart Eyes
Release DateFebruary 7, 2025
TaglineNo couple is safe.
Runtime97 minutes
DirectorJosh Ruben
Screenplay Written ByPhillip Murphy, Christopher Landon & Michael Kennedy
Based OnOriginal screenplay
Is It a Remake?No. Heart Eyes is an original romantic comedy slasher.
BudgetApproximately $18 million
Box OfficeApprox. $30.4 million domestic / Approx. $33.1 million worldwide
↑ Return to Top

👥 Main Cast

Olivia HoltAlly McCabe
Mason GoodingJay Simmonds
Gigi ZumbadoMonica
Michaela WatkinsCrystal Cane
Devon SawaDetective Zeke Hobbs
Jordana BrewsterDetective Jeanine Shaw
Yoson AnDavid
Bronwyn BradleyFran
Chris ParkerTommy
Latham GainesNico
Lauren O’HaraAdeline Garrett
Alex WalkerCollin
↑ Return to Top

🏆 Awards

⭐ Hollywood Music in Media Awards Nominee — Best Original Score, Horror / Thriller Film, Jay Wadley
⭐ Hawaii Film Critics Society Awards Nominee — IMDb lists Heart Eyes with a 2026 HFCS nomination.
⭐ IMDb currently lists the film with 3 nominations total.
⭐ No Academy Award, Golden Globe, BAFTA, or Saturn Award nominations were verified for the film.
↑ Return to Top

📖 Short Plot Summary

For several years, the Heart Eyes Killer has terrorized couples on Valentine’s Day. In Seattle, coworkers Ally and Jay are mistaken for a couple while pulling overtime, putting them directly in the masked killer’s sights. As the night turns into a bloody citywide chase, their fake-rom-com situation becomes a real fight for survival — and maybe, unfortunately for them, a real date.
↑ Return to Top

Key Quotes

“No couple is safe.” — Tagline
“Stay single. Stay safe.” — Tagline
“For the past several years, the Heart Eyes Killer has wreaked havoc on Valentine’s Day.” — Official synopsis
“This Valentine’s Day, no couple is safe.” — Official synopsis
↑ Return to Top

💡 Trivia

Director

  • Heart Eyes was directed by Josh Ruben, known for blending horror and comedy in projects like Scare Me and Werewolves Within.
  • Ruben came aboard the film on Valentine’s Day 2024 and completed the project in less than a year.
  • The screenplay was written by Phillip Murphy, Christopher Landon, and Michael Kennedy.
  • The movie mixes two very different formulas: a glossy rom-com setup and a holiday slasher body count.

Cast / Casting

  • Olivia Holt stars as Ally McCabe, a Seattle advertising worker having a spectacularly bad Valentine’s Day.
  • Mason Gooding plays Jay Simmonds, Ally’s coworker and accidental “date” for the evening of murder.
  • Devon Sawa and Jordana Brewster play detectives Zeke Hobbs and Jeanine Shaw.
  • Gigi Zumbado plays Monica, Ally’s friend, while Michaela Watkins plays Crystal Cane, Ally and Jay’s boss.

Soundtrack / Score

  • The score was composed by Jay Wadley.
  • Lakeshore Records released the original motion picture soundtrack digitally on February 14, 2025.
  • Wadley’s score received a Hollywood Music in Media Awards nomination for Best Original Score in a horror / thriller film.
  • The music supports the film’s tonal mashup: slick romantic comedy one minute, bloody slasher mayhem the next.

Location

  • The story is set in Seattle, Washington.
  • Despite the Seattle setting, the film was shot in Auckland, New Zealand.
  • Filming took place in New Zealand in June 2024.
  • The Seattle setting gives the movie a rainy, urban Valentine’s-night backdrop while production used New Zealand locations to stand in for the city.

Behind-The-Scenes

  • The film was produced by Spyglass Media Group and Divide/Conquer.
  • Screen Gems released the film in North America through Sony Pictures Releasing.
  • The movie opened theatrically in the United States on February 7, 2025, one week before Valentine’s Day.
  • The film grossed approximately $33.1 million worldwide against an estimated $18 million budget.
  • A sequel, Heart Eyes 2, has been scheduled for release in February 2028.

Nostalgia

  • Heart Eyes continues the tradition of holiday-themed slashers, only swapping Halloween and Christmas for Valentine’s Day.
  • The film plays with romantic comedy clichés — meet-cutes, workplace chemistry, big-city dating panic — then runs them through a slasher filter.
  • It fits into the modern meta-slasher wave while also leaning into date-night horror fun.
  • For Seattle-area viewers, the setting adds a local hook, even though the movie was filmed in New Zealand.

Easter Eggs

  • The title refers to both the heart-eyes emoji and the killer’s glowing heart-shaped mask.
  • The movie’s release date was timed to land just before Valentine’s Day.
  • The tagline “Stay single. Stay safe.” turns dating-app anxiety into slasher logic.
  • The “couple-hunting killer” premise lets the film spoof romance tropes while still delivering traditional stalk-and-slash sequences.

Misc.

  • Heart Eyes is rated R for strong violence and gore, language, and some sexual content.
  • Rotten Tomatoes’ critics consensus praised the film as a mix of gory slasher and sweet rom-com.
  • The Numbers lists the opening weekend at approximately $8.3 million from 3,102 theaters.
  • Your 3 Guys and a Flick ratings page lists the episode as Episode 249, with Don rating it 3.25, Ken rating it 1.00, Jon rating it 3.25, and an overall rating of 2.50.
↑ Return to Top

🔗 Sources Cited

↑ Return to Top

Other Recommended Slasher Movies...