This week the 3 Guys head straight into the storm with the movie Identity, a twisty 2003 thriller from James Mangold that still messes with your head.

We break down the stacked cast — John Cusack, Ray Liotta, and Amanda Peet — and dig into the creative choices that make this motel nightmare tick. From hidden clues and repeating motifs to fractured psyches, nothing escapes the Guys’ scrutiny.

We unpack the infamous twist, debate whether it still lands on repeat viewings, and cover soundtrack notes, behind-the-scenes trivia, character rankings, ratings, and a final verdict that may divide the table.

If you love psychological thrillers, big swings, and heated takes — this episode is absolutely you.